Tom And Nancy’s Pizza

Simply the worst pizza I have had in the past 44 years of Pizza eating. Do not order. They used canned mushrooms and it was under done... soft no crunch or snap to the crust at all. Overall just plain disgusting, most went in the trash. We will never go back there again. I hope you saw this BEFORE you ordered.

This is by far one of THE BEST PIZZA restaurant's around!!! My wife and I use to live in NYC which as any pizza enthusiast will tell you is the Mecca of Pizza. However, with great distinction I can honestly give the coveted 5 stars to Tom & Nancy's Pizza because all the ingredients that they put into the pizza is made from scratch. The cheese that is used along with the sauce exceeds all expectations. Kurt, who is apparently is the guru of Pizza's can make ANY pizza with ANY toppings even unusual requests as long as you give him some advance notice. The crust is not too thin and definitely NOT thick. My wife and I drive all the way from Pittsford to eat this Pizza. THAT's how good it is. There is NO other pizza shop in the Monroe County vicinity that even comes close. And as mentioned before, I honestly have to say that it is better if not comparable to Pizza available in Manhattan and the Bronx. To top it off, the staff is VERY friendly and personable. ~ "Q"